Poor Piddy. After the milk carton incident, she gets her
necklace ripped from her neck, and gets slapped on the back of the head. She
then gets a message from Yaqui’s friend that she wants to fight her at a park
at six. When Piddy doesn’t show up, Yaqui and her gang of friends find her and
Yaqui attacks her, and not just attacks her but completely humiliates her.
Yaqui manages to not only beat her up outside of her own home, but Piddy gets
her bra and shirt ripped off, and is exposed to her neighborhood, and also the
internet because Yaqui’s friend is recording it. This in particular angers me,
because in a way it’s an invasion of privacy. To have your body exposed to the
world without your consent is never okay obviously, but I have to imagine that
it would be extremely traumatizing. It reminded me of this video that went
viral all over the internet and it was a very similar fight in the book, where
two young ladies get into a physical altercation that leads to one of girl’s
breasts exposed, and people were commenting on the video laughing and thinking
it was funny, it made me sick. It really made me upset that not only did it
happen in the book, it happens in real life too. Piddy is forced to know that a
lot of people have watched this video, and has to relive that moment over and
over again because it’s now on online.
Something I can really relate to is Piddy lashing out on
people. When I was in high school I had my car keyed twice, I had trash thrown
on my car three times, one of those times at home, and I had a group of girls
that hated me and I don’t think I ever talked to any of them once. When my car
got keyed and trashed I started to lash out on people because I was so
frustrated that people that I didn’t even know would do this, and didn’t like
me for any particular reason. I felt I had to be mean to certain people and
build walls up in order to cope with what was happening and being said about
me, I was always really paranoid, which is how Piddy felt, even when it was all
over. Looking back at it now I realize it was only one little part of my entire
life, and I’m too old to really care about it now. Built up anger is hard to
overcome when you feel you don’t have any real outlet. I really relate to Piddy
in some ways.
I’m not sure how I feel about the ending of the book, the
faculty gets an anonymous tip (Rob) that Piddy is being bullied, which she then
admits to it, and then the ending is her going back to her old school and being
accepted into the Science school. I’m not sure how realistic that is. From my
experience if I was being bullied in school I wouldn’t be able to just transfer
to a different school, especially in the middle of the year. Most kids find a
way to deal with bullying instead of just transferring, the ending made the
solution sound so simple, when that’s usually not the case.

Reality, I completely agree with your opinion on the ending of the book. It didn't seem realistic to me at all. I feel that if this were to have taken place in real life, it would have ended with Piddy getting beaten up for being a narc, or with Piddy punching Yaqui's face in and end with them both being suspended for being in a fight. This ended up forced.
ReplyDeleteI am glad that everything worked out at the end for Piddy- but in some ways it only seems- yeah- worked out superficially. Piddy will still have to face bullies and Yaqui will probably still bully. Someone else on here said that it seemed like a bandaid for the situation- forget who it was- but thats a good analogy for it in some ways I think.
ReplyDeleteI agree, the ending did seem maybe a little too simple to be true. I was expecting something else to happen. I was happy that she was able to get away from the bullying, but something just didn't feel right with her almost running away from the problem.
ReplyDeleteReality - within the last couple of weeks I saw two females fighting in the parking lot of the Kzoo transit station. Since I was on a bus, I couldn't hear. So, yes, fights really do happen, still. It makes me wonder how many people are not able to let go of anger like you were able to do.
ReplyDelete